Courts and the rule of law

Under the rule of law, laws bind everyone, the state included, and independent courts protect people's rights.

5 min read

What is a Rechtsstaat?

Germany is a Rechtsstaat, a state under the rule of law. That means everyone who lives here, and the state itself, must obey the law. The police, public authorities and the government may do only what the law allows. If you think an authority has acted wrongly, you can challenge it and take it to court.

The rule of law also means nobody may be arrested without cause. Only the state may arrest and hold someone, and only on a legal basis; a judge decides on detention. Punishments must be humane: the death penalty has been abolished and torture is forbidden. A fine, by contrast, is an ordinary penalty.

The three branches

State power is divided:

The press is vital to democracy, but it is not a branch of state power. There is also no such thing as a "directive" branch. The courts are not part of the executive; they form the judiciary.

Judges

Judges work in the courts and deliver judgments. They belong to the Judikative (judiciary). They are independent: no one may tell them how to decide, and they are bound only by the law.

Criminal trials often also involve Schöffen (lay judges). These are ordinary citizens with no legal training who serve as honorary judges and decide on guilt and sentence together with the professional judges.

A case before a court is called a Prozess (trial or legal proceedings). A criminal trial happens when someone is charged with a crime; until the verdict, that person is presumed innocent. For advice and representation in court, you go to a Rechtsanwalt (lawyer).

Different courts

There are separate courts for different kinds of dispute. Conflicts at work, for example, go to the Arbeitsgericht (labour court). Someone who thinks a dismissal is unfair can file a Kündigungsschutzklage (unfair dismissal claim) there. There is a short deadline for this.

The top court for constitutional questions is the Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe. It interprets the Basic Law and checks whether laws are compatible with it.

Protecting democracy

A party that aims to set up a dictatorship is unconstitutional. Even so, a party can be banned only if it actively fights the constitution, meaning it wants to abolish the free democratic order. Only the Federal Constitutional Court can decide that.

Challenging a wrong decision

The rule of law helps in everyday life, too. If an authority sends you a decision or bill that you think is wrong, you can often lodge a Widerspruch (formal objection). Against a wrong tax assessment you file an Einspruch (objection) with the tax office. How and by when is stated at the end of the decision letter. The authority then has to review the case again.

Remember

  • Rule of law: everyone, including the state, must obey the law.
  • Three branches: legislative, executive, judiciary; the press is not a branch of state power.
  • Judges belong to the judiciary, are independent and deliver judgments.
  • The Federal Constitutional Court interprets the Basic Law and alone can ban a party.
  • You challenge a wrong decision by an authority with a Widerspruch, a tax assessment with an Einspruch.

Practise these questions (12)

Practise freeMock test